That said, I have not been lazy, so here is kind of an update.
Those of you who follow this Blog for some time might have read my thoughts on the Trollstein knife I made an interpretation of some time ago. I have since used it pretty much and sensibly hard. And I am just amazed how great the concept is. I do love Puukkot, but they are not perfect, e.g. for food prepping. I do love bushcraft knives, but those that cater more to a hunting target group are not perfect for woodcarving. And, well, let us be honest, woodcarving and foraging and food prepping is what I do. And for extreme batoning I do carry an axe. Or whittle a glut or a wedge. I find that the Trollstein knife is pretty much catering for most of the stuff I do admireably. I even prefer it to most kitchen knives when cooking. As a side note, I guess that this might perfectly aligned with what the original user might have done with it in the iron age. And given that it also excels in the kitchen, it also might not fail in a hunting scenario.
Thing is, while it is not exactly huge, I was thinking about something smaller. Over here, if you come across people in the woods and you got some kind of belt knife, they might pretty much freak out. Also, I wanted something even more dexterous for more woodcarving detail work but a tad sturdier than the Slöjd knife I made for myself.
Now I have been fascinated with the Sgían Dúbh and Sgían Achláis variety of knives and I have made several over the years and they were gone pretty fast. Most Sgíaine Dúbhe you can buy do have a pretty flimsy stick tang, good blade or no. I really loved the Videos by Tom Langhorne about the knives. He made himself some for bushcraft which I really liked. Look at that:
So, they are not something you can actually buy. He sold some of them to raise funds (awesome human being, btw, go over and give him a sub, I daresay you won't regret it), but they are not publicly available.
But it had my mind going for years. Because, actually, that is a pretty practical design concept. I wanted something, however, with a bit of a Trollstein knife vibe. Maybe that might not be so far away from the original historical pieces, but I really cannot say at the moment.
I put that off my mind, though. Had a lot of other stuff to consider and I cannot use the smithy at my disposal, because it is pretty far out, and I actually also didn't have the energy.
Up came another Scotsman, namely Matty Flett. His designs really spoke to me, and I tend to get pretty obsessed when I get intrigued by an idea, you know, neurospicy and all that. Have a look at what that fellow does, here:
Another awesome guy you might consider to follow. I have yet to meet a Scot I don't like at all (or someone from Ireland or Bréizh at that).
Now Matty really got that itch back into me again.
So I moved my lazy bum out to the countryside to make something for myself. I have really fallen in love with 80CrV2 steel in the last years. When you are working with an open forge, its resilience is hard to beat, and, honestly, screw those heebie jeebie goobalahbah magical sorcery steels. They can be awesome if you got some spaceship tempering ovens and excel in lab conditions, but I need to get the tempering done with my coal forge and the knife must work in real life. I mean, I do tend to take a bit of care, but I also use them pretty hard. With 80CrV2 you can get a pretty hard edge while retaining a lot of stability.I do a lot of normalizing after forging. When the blade is cooling in the process, there is plenty time to have a cuppa.
After the blade is soft enough to be easily filed, I do the grinding.
It looks pretty rough, but I honestly do no longer care a lot. Will get scratched in use anyway. Not that I do not try to get it finished as best as I could, but I do not have a belt grinder and I actually need the tools I forge. I thoroughly abuse them before mounting them, though:
In this short clip you can see me whacking the edge into the (hardened) anvil and flexing it 15 degrees in the vice. The edge showed a bit of rolling, which is perfectly okay, but no breakouts. A hard file (65HRC) can take off some small shavings, hinting of a hardness of 58-60HRC approximately (it carves the edge of a Nanus Laurinmetalli Puukko blade, which comes in at 59).
I am still thinking about whether I should redo the temper (the Trollstein knife has some 62HRC as tested with a Rockwell file and keeps up pretty well, and the Sgían Dúbh blade is way shorter). As is, it seems to be plenty hard enough for what I do.
I am still on and about on a handle. I was thinking about some oak from the old house in the woods I grew up in, but it is pretty flat. I think that I would also love some stag antler and I also have some really tough ash lying around not doing anything. It is certainly an ongoing project and certainly not the last Sgían Dúbh I will make. For some reason, that knife variety pretty much appeals to me on some primeval level of feeling, if that does make any sense. Maybe it is that it is reputed to have a history (or rather, mythology) to it.
So, I hope to keep you posted.
All the best for you guys, and take care, I really appreciate you being around!









































